Donna Kauffman Icon

So…how sexy is too sexy? And what isn’t sexy enough? These are the burning questions of the universe I ponder. (Clearly, I need to get a life, but that is a topic for another blog…)

Here’s the thing: I have two very different covers for my next two releases. Both are with the same publisher, both books have the same tone, more or less. There is a wee bit of suspense in the second, but the heat factor is the same. One cover is cute, bordering on sweet. The other cover is…well, two words. Hubba and hubba. My feeling is that the second cover more clearly represents the content of the books and that the first might not draw the readers who would enjoy my work. And, in fact, might attact some who will be surprised to find a wee bit o’ steam between the covers.

However, I’ve gotten some different reactions to them. First, I should say that both covers are very tastefully done, featuring fully clothed heroes, so nothing overtly brazen or naughty. Very PG. It’s how these guys are clothed, posed, and well…you get my drift. So, while most readers liked both covers, many agreed with me that the second one was more in line with what they thought represented the work. But there were some who really enjoyed a cover with a sweeter, not so in-your-face look.

Hence my quandary…when is sexy too sexy? And when isn’t it sexy enough? Would you rather have a cover that makes your pulse take a little leap, or would you prefer to keep all the pulse-leaping between the covers?